Welfare Benefits Conditioned Upon Drug Testing: Will It Pass Muster?
On May 31st, 2011, Florida passed a law that requires all adult applicants for cash benefits from Florida’s welfare system to be tested for drugs. The new law requires welfare recipients to pay for the drug test, but it raises their initial welfare payment to cover the cost of the test if they pass. People who fail the test become ineligible for welfare for a year, but this is decreased to six months if they prove they have successfully completed drug treatment at their expense. A second failed test makes them ineligible for welfare for three years.
In recent years, over half of the states have considered bills that would subject welfare recipients to drug testing. Proponents of this new legislative trend argue that drug testing welfare recipients saves taxpayers dollars, insures that children of recipients are adequately cared for, and prevents abuse of controlled substances. Florida’s Governor Rick Scott contends that taxpayers should not have to subsidize drug use. In addition, the government’s special interest in drug testing welfare recipients outweighs the privacy rights of recipients not suspected of drug use. The state has a special need to make sure welfare funds are used for their intended purposes and not for procuring controlled substances. Drug use by welfare recipients not only has a negative impact on their ability to get and keep a job, but is also a criminal activity that directly endangers both the public and the people the program is designed to assist.
However, many claim the law is unconstitutional because suspicionless drug testing of all welfare recipients violates the Fourth Amendment protection against unreasonable search and seizures. The majority of proposed legislation, like Florida’s new law, imposes testing without regard to suspected drug use. This suspicionless drug testing subjects welfare recipients to humiliating intrusions and violates their basic Fourth Amendment right to privacy and bodily autonomy.
Conducting drug tests on welfare applicants as a condition of receiving benefits is highly debated issue. Whether Florida’s new law and other similar legislation will survive challenges in court likely depends on whether the court determines the government’s interests outweigh the Fourth Amendment’s protections.
Please contact one of our attorneys at Miller|Conway if you or someone you know needs a lawyer. We are here for you when you need us.
